Text Box: DVDSleuth.com

Text Box:   

   


DVDSleuth.com is your source for daily Blu-ray Disc & DVD news and reviews.

 

Batman: The Dark Knight Returns, Part 1 (2012)

Warner Home Video
Blu-ray Disc Released: 9/25/2012

All Ratings out of

Movie:

Video:
1/2
Audio:

Extras:


Review by Mike Long, Posted on 9/30/2012

I sometimes feel that I'm a harsh critic (I do want things to be as good as they can be), but I do give credit where credit is due and credit must go to the DC Universe animation group at Warner Home Video. These guys understand how it should be done -- You take your best, most famous, most critically lauded comic book stories and you turn them into animated features. No need in taking a chance with writing original stories featuring your most popular characters -- this is a company which understands how to give the public what they actually want. Superman, The Justice League, and Green Lantern have all gotten this treatment, and now it's time for another saga from the adventures of Batman. But, this time, the DC folks have gone to one of the most popular and influential comics of the 20th century with Batman: The Dark Knight Returns, Part 1.

The Dark Knight Returns is set in a future Gotham City. (I guess it could argued that it's an alternate future, but we won't get into that.) Bruce Wayne (voiced by Peter Weller) is now an old man and he's long since retired from being Batman. Commissioner Gordon (voiced by David Selby) is older as well, and he's on the verge of retirement. He's aware that Bruce Wayne is Batman and the too reminisce about the old days. A group of thugs callings themselves The Mutants have been staging a crime spree in Gotham and this gets Wayne's attention. Things get even more interesting when a seemingly rehabilitated and rebuilt Harvey Dent (voiced by Wade Williams) is released from Arkham and promptly disappears. These events cause Wayne to once again don the Batman suit, despite the protests of Alfred (voiced by Michael Jackson...who I presume is not that Michael Jackson). As Batman takes on The Mutants and Two-Face, he piques the curiosity of a young girl named Carrie Kelly (voiced by Ariel Winter), who gets a Robin costume and begins to pursue the Caped Crusader. Can an old man and a girl take down a crime syndicate?

The Dark Knight Returns is based on the 1986 comic book limited series by famed artist/writer Frank Miller. This series is credited with recreating the Batman mythos and giving us the character with which we are most familiar today. Miller brought a darkness to both the character and Gotham City, creating a Batman who saw himself as operating outside of the law and one who would go to extremes to see justice being done. This clearly had an influence on Tim Burton's Batman, but the shades of The Dark Knight Returns can really be felt in Christopher Nolan's Dark Knight Trilogy. Those films, especially The Dark Knight Rises share common themes of Batman being away from Gotham and forces arising intent on taking over the entire city. And there's no denying that the dark and brooding nature of the Bruce Wayne seen in The Dark Knight Returns can be seen in Christian Bale's character and most any depiction of Batman since the late 80s. (The fight between The Mutants' leader and Batman reminded me of the slugfests between Batman and Bane in The Dark Knight Rises.)

The Dark Knight Returns has been on my list of "things I intend to read" for decades, but as I'm A) more of a Marvel person, and B) always reviewing movies, I've never gotten around to it. Thus, I can't say how must justice (no pun intended) this adaptation does to the comics. But, I can say that I certainly enjoyed this movie and it's one of the most satisfying DC Comics animated projects yet. (Based on a synopsis of The Dark Knight Returns which I read, it looks like they stuck to the story and I would imagine that they wouldn't want to mess with some a famous property.) While remaining within its PG-13 confines, the movie presents us with a violent and dark depiction of Gotham City. From the outset, the movie grabs us with its visuals and the anticipation that Batman will be appearing at sometime. While we're obviously familiar with Bruce Wayne/Batman, Commissioner Gordon, and Alfred, the movie does a good job of introducing us to new characters like Carrie Kelly (listen closely to the dialogue of her off-screen parents to get a feel for their household) and The Mutants. The action scenes are very well-done and clearly aren't afraid to go for broke. As this is Part 1, it ends with a great cliffhanger, which leaves us longing for Part 2.

Along with Watchmen, The Dark Knight Returns is the most important and influential DC title of the 80s. And just as we got the "Motion Comic" and feature film of Watchmen, we now have an animated version of The Dark Knight Returns. It seems rather obvious that DC would want to adapt this title, but one has to wonder why they waited so long. For those who are unfamiliar with the comic, this movie will feel like a copy of other Batman projects, as they won't understand that it came first. (Just like how those who don't know comics thought that everything in The Incredibles was original). Whatever the case, DC needs to keep making these adaptations. Marvel has taken the hint and brought us properties with Thor and The X-Men, but DC took the reins on this and I can't wait for The Dark Knight Returns, Part 2.

Batman: The Dark Knight Returns, Part 1 has a very interesting version of the Batmobile on Blu-ray Disc courtesy of Warner Home Video. The movie has been letterboxed at 1.78:1 and the Disc contains an AVC 1080p HD transfer which runs at an average of 18 Mbps. The image is very sharp and clear, showing no grain or defects from the source materials. As one would imagine, this is a dark movie, but the image is never overly dark. The colors, when they appear, look good, most notably reds and blues. The animation looks good -- there is no stuttering of the image and no jagged lines. The image is detailed and shows a nice amount of depth. The Disc carries a DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track which runs at 48 kHz and an average of 4.2 Mbps. The track provides clear dialogue and sound effects. This is a powerful track which offers loads of surround and subwoofer effects. The action scenes bring us a nice balance of stereo and surround effects -- these are nicely detailed and we can clearly here the audio moving from side to side and front to back. The subwoofer effects, most notably from the Batmobile, are palpable, but not distorted.

The Batman: The Dark Knight Returns, Part 1 contains an assortment of trailers and previews for other projects, but only a few real extra features. "Her Name is Carrie...Her Role is Robin" (12 minutes) is a discussion of the importance of making Robin a female in The Dark Knight Returns. Members of the DC Comics family discuss the cultural impact of Frank Miller's creation and how Carrie Kelly further helped the book to shake up the comic book world. The piece then looks at other female comic book characters. "Batman and Me: The Bob Kane Story" (38 minutes) is a detailed documentary about the creator of Batman. Through photos, archive interviews, and comment from those who knew Kane, we learn about his life and legacy. The Disc also contains two bonus episodes of Batman: The Animated Series which feature Two-Face.

Review Copyright 2012 by Mike Long