Text Box: DVDsleuth.com

Text Box:   


DVDSleuth.com is your source for daily DVD news and reviews.


Stranger Than Fiction (2006)

Sony Pictures Home Entertainment
Blu-ray Disc Released: 12/2/2008

All Ratings out of
Video: 1/2
Audio: 1/2

Review by Mike Long, Posted on 11/20/2008

There's an old Queensryche song which contains the line, "Strange how laughter looks like crying with no sound" -- thus we have the fine line between comedy and drama, happiness and sorrow. Many actors like to move between these two worlds and the skilled ones make it look easy. When Jim Carrey made the leap from comic buffoon to tragic hero in The Truman Show, it was mesmerizing, showing us a side of the actor which we hadn't seen. Now, Will Ferrell attempts to make a similar leap in a similar film, Stranger Than Fiction, but can a comedian become too serious?

Ferrell stars in Stranger Than Fiction as Harold Crick, a mild-mannered IRS employee. Harold lives alone and leads a very solitary life. He does the same routine everyday, and he thrives on numbers, as he counts the strokes when he brushes his teeth, counts the number of steps to the bus stop, and can quickly do math in his head. One day, Harold's life takes a very bizarre turn when he begins to hear a voice narrating his life. The female voice doesn't tell Harold what to do, but rather she simply describes what Harold is doing. At first, Harold doesn't know what to make of this, but as the voice continues, Harold begins to unravel.

At the same time, we meet author Kay Eiffel (Emma Thompson). Kay is a neurotic, standoffish writer who is attempting to complete a novel about a man named Harold Crick. Her publisher sends Penny Escher (Queen Latifah) to ensure that Kay completes her novel on time, much to Kay's chagrin.

As Harold realizes that the voice is a narrator, he seeks the help of literature professor Jules Hilbert (Dustin Hoffman), who attempts to assist Harold in deciding what kind of story he is in. Meanwhile, Harold has been assigned to audit a bakery owner named Ana Pascal (Maggie Gyllenhaal). Ana is a modern-day revolutionary who purposely neglected to pay all of her taxes and she immediately resents Harold. Yet, Harold finds himself drawn to this fiery woman. As if all of this craziness isn't enough for Harold, he hears Kay's voice say that he is going to die.

You can no doubt tell that Stranger Than Fiction has a lot of story going on and the story it presents is quite interesting. Screenwriter Zach Helm is clearly mining Charlie Kaufman territory, but that's OK, as the film certainly has the Kaufman quality, but it never feels like a rip-off. (While the overall script has a Charlie Kaufman feel, the idea that a watch accelerates the story reminded me of Douglas Adams.) Had this been a short film, then the story would have most likely played like an episode of The Twilight Zone, where the uptight and anal Harold begins to hear a voice and his tidy life is changed. But, as a feature length film, Helm has been able to add many more dimensions and characters to Harold's tale, as we watch the man search the meaning of the voice and also watch as he find love. At the same time, we get the story of Kay Eiffel, a successful writer who appears to be quite mad. I enjoyed the juxtaposition here as Kay, the respected artist, clearly has issues, while Harold, the plain tax agent, is perceived as being crazy because he hears a voice.

Director Mark Forster has done a fine job of taking Helm's script and translating it to the screen. He takes all of the characters and information and presents it in a way which is never overwhelming. Forster also allows the tone of the story to dictate the look and feel of the film and this is where Stranger Than Fiction runs into trouble. At the beginning, we are introduced to two rather dour characters -- Harold is a fastidious and lonely man and Kay is a bizarre and cranky woman. Thus, the film has a cold and sterile look and feel which reflects these characters. Forster fills the film with sharp angles and cool colors which mirror the lives of the characters. I don't think I'm giving anything away here when I say that as Harold's old life comes apart, he begins to loosen up somewhat -- even when things look grave. Yet, the overall tone of the movie never changes. Forster continues to allow the film to be emotionally closed off and this is disconcerting to the viewer. The visuals don't match the characters behavior and the difference create distance from the film. (At one point during the movie David Cronenberg called me and said, "Can you believe how sterile this movie feels?")

The same can be said of Will Ferrell's performance. This man, known for his non-sensical ranting in film likes Anchorman and Talladega Nights, really reels it in here, and he plays Harold as he is written, as a sad and lonely man. (Compare this to Jim Carrey in The Truman Show where Carrey got a little nutty at times.) Yet, even when Harold become happy or upset, I still felt that Ferrell was holding back too much. Thus, Harold remains unapproachable throughout the film. Ferrell's performance isn't bad, it just doesn't serve the film from beginning to end. The other actors in the movie are stupendous. I've found Maggie Gyllenahall to be a bit of a downer in other films, but she really lights up the screen here, despite that nasty tattoo. The controlled insanity displayed by Dustin Hoffman nods to what Ferrell's performance should have been like. And Emma Thompson, who looks as if she just woke up, is scarily good as the unstable Kay.

Based on the trailer for Stranger Than Fiction, I had high hopes for the film. And also based on the trailer, I was expecting the film to be more of a surrealist fantasy/comedy. Instead, the movie is a more serious look at how people can be alive and yet, not living. The movie has some funny moments and some potentially touching ones, but the overall sterile and cold tone of the film dilutes many of these emotions. Stranger Than Fiction is certainly unique and interesting, but the lack of charm hurts the film.

Stranger Than Fiction has auditory hallucinations on Blu-ray Disc courtesy of Sony Pictures Home Entertainment. The film has been letterboxed at 1.85:1 and the Disc contains a MPEG-2 1080p transfer which runs at an average of 28 Mbps. The image is very sharp and clear, showing no grain and no defects from the source material. The colors look very good and the image is never overly bright. The minimalist look of the film lends to the excellent depth to the image. There are many scenes where Harold stands still and we can really see how he stands out from the background. I did note that the image was a bit soft at times. The Disc contains a Dolby TrueHD 5.1 audio track which runs at 48 kHz and an average of 2.0 Mbps. The track provides clear dialogue and sound effects. The stereo effects are quite good, showing nice speaker separation. These effects are nicely detailed, especially in the city street scenes. The surround sound effects are good at times, most notably during the wrecking ball scene. This scene also offers some nice bass effects.

The Blu-ray Disc features a number of extras. We begin with an AUDIO COMMENTARY featuring Director Marc Forster and actors Dustin Hoffman & Will Ferrell. This is a fun track, as Hoffman and Ferrell share many stories and generally have a good time. There is a second commentary with Forster, Production Designer Kevin Thompson, Visual Effects Designer Kevin Haug, Director of Photography Roberto Schaefer, Producer Lindsay Doran, and Executive Producer Eric Kopeloff. The speakers all offer their input and try not to talk over one another. This does get a bit dry at times. The Disc contains 9 DELETED AND EXTENDED SCENES which run about 7 minutes. Each features a text introduction which establishes the scene. There is some funny stuff here and we get to see some improvisation which didn't make it into the finished film. "Actors in Search of a Story" (19 minutes) focuses on each of the main actors and their characters. We get an overview of director Marc Forster and the crew he uses on his films in "Building the Team" (8 minutes). "On Location in Chicago" (10 minutes) explores why Chicago was chosen and where certain things were shot. Writer Zach Helm talks about the script and the tone of the film is discussed in "Words on a Page" (9 minutes). The 17-minute "Picture a Number: The Evolution of a G.U.I." examines the graphics and on-screen numbers which are used throughout the film. (For the ignorant like me, G.U.I. = Graphic User Interface.) "On the Set" (3 minutes) is a montage of on-location footage.

Review Copyright 2008 by Mike Long